Christian/Muslim ThreadsNo Proof Quran Copied from Bible, Gnostic or Jewish SourcesTo Loki And it only ends as 'arguments'. That is far from giving us PROOF. He could at least gave us some refernce to studies made, quoting historical datings, etc. 'Accusations' without facts cannot be close to Truth. 3) Now, that's STATISTICS. How did Loki come to that figure? 4) Are you saying the Prophet can read Aramaic, Syriac and Coptic? Waraqa was reported to have translated the Gospel into Hebrew... but the Prophet can read those languages? Wow... that is something new! 5) The hadith mentioned that the Prophet only met Waraqa twice. To be his teacher, I would only assumed that there should be close and constant interaction between the Prophet and Waraqa. That is not what the hadith says. Now, unless Loki can come up with another source which says that Muhammad (pbuh) studied or was in constant contact with Waraqa, then Loki is wrong again! 6) Waraqa died 3 years after Muhammad (pbuh) received the revelations. If he had already absorbed what he learnt from Waraqa, he could just continue with the revelations and gather more followers to the faith. Yet, as Loki mentioned the revelations stopped for some time. 7) I am not sure what Loki is talking about the story of the marble and the tar. 8) Scriptual research, you say? Then tell us what you have learnt about this remarkable carbon dating. 9) History is always associated with events and dates. If they cannot give any accurate dating, they give some dates that are closer to the events. You have not seen any of your 'historians' giving the dates of the Arabic Gospel of Infancy, have you? Yes, in some cases historians do interprete/fit certain events with REASONABLE ARGUMENTS. In many cases, they provided links and studies made on some events to back up their claims. As far as possible, they are trying to be objective. Unfortunately, what I have seen in your arguments, are pure speculations... you have not even provided any studies by scholars to back up your claim. Mostly, it is based on your conjectures. 10) Once again, there is really NO PROOF that the Quran borrowed from Gnostic source! salam |
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame