it isn't? if you did that today with a book from Stephen King, you'd be sued to poordom...
Let me break it down to you, Qur'an approaves somethings in the bible, the tings which have not been corrupted, also if i apply your logic then Isaac newton copied Gottfried Leibniz calculus? No they both came up with it. But if we use ur sense, then Newton stole leibnzi work :roll: and everyone would kno that claim is ridicoulous.
those i quoted was NOT from the new testament but from heretic gospels... meaning gospels fabricated by people centuries after Jesus lived.
And what does that mean, mary is being much more praised? are you trying to sell a car here? or debate truth?
lool do u have actaul proof that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) actaully had those fabricated gospels? If so, show me HARD PROOF NOT BASED ON ASSUMPTIONS. When you talk about Qur'an borrowing that is a Fallacy statement buddy. and no Mary is regarded HIGH in islam. Im trying to point out the diff between how mary is talked about in GOspels compared to the Qur'an.
PostPosted: Sun Mar 13, 2005 05:49 pm Post subject:
Quote:
lool tatz not stealing mr. I see similiar things but when you read it, it is of course different
it isn't? if you did that today with a book from Stephen King, you'd be sued to poordom...
Quote:
there is more information on mary then in the new testament, mary is praised much more then in the new testament.
those i quoted was NOT from the new testament but from heretic gospels... meaning gospels fabricated by people centuries after Jesus lived.
And what does that mean, mary is being much more praised? are you trying to sell a car here? or debate truth?
Quote:
Its not stealing? the way it is presented is so much different. and may i aks where your proof is? HOW,WHEN,WHERE did muhamma (PBUH) steal verses from the bible?
it's not that different really, and it's not the only story...
HOW? WHEN? WHERE?
i wasn't there with him you know, we can only guess about that since he came into contact with so many people in so many places who could of preached him this... that's not really important who gave it to muhammed... yet what we do know, considering the odds, and the tales of the acient accusations in the quran and using rational thinking... is that muhammed most likely repeated what others told him...
OO ok so you can only GUESS loolz, YOUR ENTIRE BELIEF that the Qur'an is copied is All fallacy statements!! lool More of your assumptions. Muhammad *PBUH was ILLITERATE, KEEP THAT IN MIND, and if he did copy it. THere would of been numerous hadiths on it. but YOU HAVE NO SOLID PROOF, just FALLACY statements.
so? what does that change anything?
Im showing you the history when Surah mary was revealed. It was in Mecca. Provide valid proof that Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) has came in contact with the Gospel during that time.