Christian/Muslim ThreadsWhy muslims cast stones at a well in Mecca.When you were a Muslim does not mean you were a practicing muslim, or was educated properly about Islam. There are plenty of Muslims born into Muslim families [not to mention reverts] and are ignorant of their own faith whom merely just claim to be muslim per culture and tradition but dont practice their religion as a muslim is suppose to do. However we will answer most of your comments you made above in one nutshell seeing that you were supposedly a former muslim seem to have a lack of research on the topic. Bukhari's collection that he chose to be "Sahih" was based on Isnad ie the transmission realiabilty of a hadith which was solely based on "hear say". You should have learnt this if you had read his biography and his own words about his collection. He never claimed his work was infallible, but made it clear it was his opinion of the authenticity of "Isnad" and that his work is subject to error. After Bukhari collected what he, in his best human effort with the sources that was available to him at that time, never tested his collection of Isnad with the Quran when a hadeeth it self deemed that anything written other than Quran must be confirmed with the Quran. Bukhari's student known as Muslim in his collection called "Sahih Muslim" didnt accept some of his teacher's Isnad collection whom also re-evaluated his work and came out with about 4,000 fewer than the 6,000 his teacher approved of. Thus his student rejected about 2,000 hadeeths of Bukhari, in which the collection "Sahih Muslim" is also a secondary authoritive source in Islam to some and to others a third in which the Quran is the primary source above all of them. Sahih Muslim's work was also based on "Isnad" also which was not authenticated by Quran. Imam Nawawi in his book called "RiyaadhiyyusSalaheen" whom re-evaluated all the claimed "SAHIH" hadeeths by both Bukhari and Muslim, were authenticated by Quran approving of only a fewer, about 700 years ago, to that which was originally selected by the first collectors. All this talk about hadeeth this and that you all abviously have no clue of what is what. I would like one of you to get and read for your self Imam Nawawi's collection that has been authenticated by Quran which are also self authentication by validating reports, and apply your criticism that you have so wantonly been doing, or misleadingly done.
Let me quote my self. Here are verses from the Quran: The ends of the day are points of the day which are morning and evening when day begins and closes. Thus is refering to the Morning prayer called Fajr or the prayer that is done at the brake of dawn, and Maghrib or the prayer that is done after dusk before night fall. Two prayers are mentioned here and more. At the Sun's decline is the afternoon prayer when the Sun starts to decline from its zenith. This prayer is called "Zhuhr". Also the Fajr prayer is mention by name here in the Arabic. The night prayer is mentioned which is called "Ishaa" Both Asr and Zhuhr prayers are mentioned here as Asr is the late afternoon prayer and Zhuhr is the early afternoon prayer. And finally again: The middle prayer is Asr which is the third prayer out of the cycle of the entire 24 hour day. All of our prayers Fajr, Zhuhr, Asr, Maghrib, and Ishaa are all mention in the Quran in which we needed no Hadeeth to confirm. It is the Quran that confirms that autheniticity of the hadeeth on the observance of the prayers. wa alaikum assalaam dear brother, it is a pleasure to see you again and still active on these forums fee sabeelillah |
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame