Christian/Muslim ThreadsNo Proof Quran Copied from Bible, Gnostic or Jewish SourcesAineo wrote: The word 'Disprove' is to connote an argument to dispel the evidence put forward (the proof). How can I do that when what you and other Christians gave are not proof, but speculation. The topic is not whether Muhammad (pbuh) is a prophet . The topic is to see if Chrsitains have proof to say that Muhammad (pbuh) copied from the apocryphas or Jewish sources. You did not supply enough information to even make a deduction. You merely state that the two monks influenced Muhammad (pbuh) without giving any evidence whatsoever. You want me to take your words, just like that? Could Bahira be the 'teacher' of Muhammad (pbuh)? 1) Muhammad (pbuh) met Bahira during one of his business trip to Sham. He was only 12 at that time. During that brief encounter, Bahira acknowledged the Muhammad (pbuh) as the "awaited prophet". This may not be the issue but I need to point out that there were records of this encounter at Sham (sahih or not) but there was totally no record that Bahira met Muhammad at Mecca, or became intimate with him or stayed with him. That is a distortion of history. 2) In fact, after the brief encounter at Sham, there was no other records of the Prophet meeting Bahira. If he was the teacher, there would be countless articles about Bahira in many hadith when Muhammad (pbuh) received the revelations... not to mention the opportunity for Muhammad's enemies to attack him of his association with Bahira. 3) As you mentioned, Bahira was a Nestorian monk. There was no record that he was expelled from the monatery. Aineo mentioned 'it was believed' and I can only say it was only a belief, not exactly a fact. There is also no proof whatsoever that "the Qur’anic verses on the Psalms of David were actually the contribution of Bahira". 4) Btw, what happened to Aineo theory of the "two monks", the "Coptic Gospels" (you mean they have differnt Gosples?) and the apocryphals? salam |
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame