Abdullah wrote:Abdullah, even if some of the words are similar to Al-Baqarah it does not necessarily imply plagersim. Am I not allowed to use any of the words found in the Qur'an like "this", "those", "upon", etec.
Prove to me that it is unrecitable, I had no difficulty reciting it myself.
If you are correct in saying it is unrecitable, can you show me how I should have wrote it?
The rules of Tajweed and Tilawah are man made rules that came after the Qur'an was revealed. They were designed to force the Qur'an to rhyme.
LOL, read the Surah al Baqarah and then read what you wrote. u steal sentences then just change one word. And i would also like to mention another thing. You claim this isnt plagerizing, and you are allowed to "Borrow" and then when u compare the bible and qur'an you say the opposite? i find find that hypocritical. And btw did u even listen to the links i sent u ? its self explanatory. And what do you mean how i can show you how to write it?
I don't claim that the Qur'an plagerizes. I was merely showing you that your own plagerism argument against my admittedly poor attempt at a Surah, is analogous to the plagerism claim made against the Qur'an.
I see the hypocrite as the one who calls me a plageriser for mimicking Qur'anic content, and then denies that Muhammad was a plageriser for mimicking Biblical and Apocryphal content.
I do not know Arabic, I'm asking you to show me how to correct the grammatical mistakes in my attempt at a Surah. You see, if it is flawed you must be able to show me HOW it is flawed and present me with a grammatically correct rendering.