H2O wrote:Aburaees wrote:These Hadiths confirm what the Qur'an says about itself, so none of them are against the Qur'an.
Excuse me ? Do you know how many times a one hadeeth is repeated in Bukhari and Muslim ? I havent gotten the chance to post up your site quotes which you didnt have the ardacity to do. Been packing for a trip, but dont worry I will come back later with your hadeth section quotes to see how many people are actually reporting a particular hadeeth.
Aburaees wrote:The Qur'an confirms that it is self-abrogating.
Rubbish ! This is a particular muslim school of thought that you have been exposed to and adopted that all muslims do not accept. I for one and many other muslims do not believe, as the Quran mentions, abrogated aayats as to refering to within the Quran. The obrogation is mentioned as we believe is that the Quran obrogated former revelations ie aayats of the Bible etc.
For example: The revelation in the Quran for Salatal-Jumu'ah abrogates the former revelation of the Jewish Sabath and so on and so on with other revelations that were revealed by Allah to all nations of people.
Aburaees wrote:The Qur'an doesn't claim that it will not be changed.
Verily We, We have sent down the reminder and We are indeed its guardians 15:9