Liberate wrote:Using H20's logic above of disregarding contradictory ahadith will he apply the same logic to the quran because based on this logic he will have to put the quran in the bin as there are conflicting reports as to how it was compiled
Surah 3
Alif Laam Meem, (1)
Alllaah, there is no G-d except Him the Living the self Existing (2)
He sent down to you (Muhammad) the scripture in truth as a truth verifier for whatever is at hand before it......(3)
Surah 5
and We sent down to you (Muhammad) the scripture in truth as a truth verifier for whatever is at hand before it from the Book and as a Supervisor over it so judge you all between them in what Alllaah had sent down and do not follow their desireable ways away from what has come to you (Muhammad)....( 48 )
Surah 15
Verily We, We sent down the reminder and We are indeed it's guardians (9)
It means the hadeeth would go into the bin not the Quran.