Apple Pie wrote:fdjohan wrote:
Apple Pie wrote:gykimus wrote: A simple equation is this:
Revelation-to Muhammad-to scribes and companions-[memorized] by many-uthman's complition of one uniform book---that is the standing quran of today. it is that simple to understand.
Unfortunately, oral transmission does not hold any water.
Unfortunately, Bible is not free from Oral transmission.
You think that is why it was written down…? :roll:
No. Written down through the thousand years of ORAL transmission.
So…now you have reverted back to “googling” webpaste…?
Give us a direct link next time.
No. You comeback after you ready to answer my arguments. You were so stuck and speechless.
Quote:
The Koran was written-down because it was in jeopardy of becoming abrogated.
If this were not so….then it would never have been written down.
And you can't talk when we gave you the evidences from hadiths.
Hadiths
are not the Koran.
Try again.
Hadith will never be Al-Qur'an. But hadiths is the second source of Muslims. You seems too scared facing by hadiths don't you.
Quote:
Further, nowhere in the entire Koran will you find the following statements….
”I muhommad, wrote this here Koran”
Or…
”I muhommad, dictated this here Koran”
We talk about this. But then you were confused and tried to avoid many of my questions.
You
failed in your attempt to produce even one of these two statements in your book of faith.
Care to try again…?
Owned.
Why don't you face the truth. You can't deny that you are stuck many times.
Quote:
Fact is, the Koran as we know it to be today was copied from the Holy Bible almost entirely – this is what your book of faith repeatedly tells us.
There is no mystery.
There is no “prophet”.
There is simply a convoluted compilation of translated Biblical scriptures that comprise Islam's book of faith.
Interested to talk about this more seriously? or you run again?
Salaam
Again….no rebuttal from you…
Owned.
Rebuttal of what? You come with nothing but with your childish claims. Are you come with references and arguments? NADA ...ZIP..ZERO.
Come with more mature discussion.
Salaam