Christian/Muslim ThreadsNo Proof Quran Copied from Bible, Gnostic or Jewish Sources
acctually no i do not have to show that it was known in arabic... the fact that the quran has these stories is a proof in itself that they were available to him... who he received it from and in what language that would of been commes second place. If a plain crashes and you don't know the direction it came from, doesn't mean the debris of the plain doesn't excist. as much as you got 'modern research' on these books to refute mine. Tisdall is outdated, did he ever use carbon dating i ask you? then when there are finer methods for determing the date of a book, why do you keep sticking to the opinion of one man. and i have given you no determint names whatsoever relaxjack, it might as been a person who teached him who wasn't mentioned in the hadiths and quran... you immediatly assume that if a person isn't mentioned in one of those, then that person must have not excisted... like i said to Abdullah before, the case in proving who and how he got his stories from is unproveable because the only time we could of done that with certainity, is when muhammed was still alive... after his death the only thing you have is the evidence of plagiarism and the speculation of possibilities in regard of how he got to know them. Well others did point out that he learned from them, it's even in the quran! a man dictated to him tales of the ancient of course when such criticism arised in that time he immediatly putteth his apologetics in the quran of wich his reply was "no it isn't so" very convincing! and the early muslims were never really convinced of muhammed's preaching to begin with but more intimidated by his power and persecutions. and his enemies were mostly pagans, he had great respect for people of the book (at least some of the times) and came many times in contact with them according to the hadiths. there is, it's called the quran... your only kicking and screaming because you don't know who and how he took it from, while you do or should know that it's taken... and that is far more important. |
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame