PostPosted: Sun Mar 13, 2005 05:57 pm Post subject:
Abdullah wrote:
Quote:
Those criteria you supplied us with aren't specified in the Qur'an as part of the challenge.
All we need to do is produce something similar.
Can you provide us with criteria that are ONLY from the Qur'an and the Sunnah without bringing someone elses "made up" rules fro the challenge?
before you speak its best if you actaully read the thread. Its self-explanatory. and no i wont tell you the details because it is already written in that article, if you are too lazy to read it then its your loss.
I have already read it, and no I'm not being lazy. I am merely requesting evidence from the Qur'an or the Sunnah for the Criteria that you claim.
The verse you supplied only tell us to produce a Surah like it, but doesn't tell us what qualifies as a Surah like it.
You also posted no Hadiths.
You are only using outside sources.
Can you imagine what you would tell me if I tried proving my point with outside sources?
You could probably tell me that you won't accept anything from outside the Qur'an and Sunnah as evidence against it.
wow r u serious, u cant even comprehend wat was writing? ok THe qur'an is unique in its style and character, Use Common sense, if the Qur'an is written in a unique way without rhyming and poetry, then you are gonna have to produce a chapter with the SAME STYLE. read the link on what styles the Qur'an is composed of, you take those styles and make another chapter, IT ISNT THAT hard to understand!