Kyas
your refutation of the contradiction is without basis, IT CLEALY CONTRADICTS ITSELF.
In Islam I believe you are taught that the evil one can blind the truth from the eyes of the non-believer, correct? Then based upon your responses, you must ask yourself if you have been blinded if you cannot see the obvious contradictions present.
Just a thought, we must all "self-examine" and hope God reveals the truth to our hearts.