Christian/Muslim Threads2nd contradictions in the Quran backed up by History!But according to your teachings the Bible says: So how could you apply your reasoning towards a statement such as "inshaaAllah" used by Allah in the third person ? But of course here is the prejudice in your reasoning. You dont believe the Quran is the word of Allah (G-D) so that is why you fathomed such a statment. Does G-D tell us his will ? We dont know his will except that what he has revealed to the Prophets for us humans to do and what not to do. Did G-D tell us that he was going to ALLOW 9/11 to occure ? But it happened right ? So he willed it to happened didnt he ? Did he know what those people (whoever they were) were plotting such a thing. G-D had ample time to stop such a thing, but he didnt, he allowed it, allowed all those thousands of people to die, Christians, Jews (?), and Muslims in those buildings. This is "Maa shaaAllah" in Arabic meaning "Allah willed it, or What Allah desired". Also, where ever you see in the Quran "If Allah wills, or Allah willing, or What Allah wills, or What Allah desires" is not always translated from "inshaaAllah" but "law shaaAllah" . They both mean the samething but have different significances in the Arabic language in which the english CANNOT convey. You may know what it means but you dont know what its significance is. "in shaa Allah" (If Allah wills) signifies the achievable that may or may not happen, which depends on the context it is being used in with other verb tense words in the Quran. If the Verb Tense in the statement of Quran it is being used in is absolute then it is clear that act will occure. "law shaa Allah" (If Allah wills) signifies the achievable that will not happen. When Allah says "In Shaa Allah" in the Quran refering to himself, in which Muhammad is the transmitter of Allah's message to mankind, where the statement is not absolute denotes that the author (Allah) does not wish to disclose his desire in permiting or not permiting a particular act to happen. How can a being that is not omnipotent whom is limited in free will say such a thing ? Only a being that is Omnipotent and has total free will can make such a statement. Muhammad was the transmitter of the Message from Allah whom was not speaking of himself. If the message of the Quran was always in the first person then Muhammad's people would think that he was claiming himself to be Allah. When Allah does speak in First person it is directed to Muhammad in the singular address (in the Arabic) and when it is a genereal statment (in the Arabic) it is in the third person as Muhammad is the receiver and transmitter of the message. The Response To add more about your self Allah says:
|
🌈Pride🌈 goeth before Destruction
When 🌈Pride🌈 cometh, then cometh Shame